Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque lobortis augue nec urna. Sed luctus, arcu ut feugiat sodales, dui nibh ultricies velit, vel placerat diam turpis in leo. Etiam aliquam laoreet turpis. Etiam lobortis nibh vel velit. Integer eleifend nisl id lorem. Suspendisse iaculis quam vel sapien.
This entire article is republished from an earlier time, with a few minor changes. All comments/links have been kept in-tact and should be skimmed by previous readers to avoid comment content duplication.
*****
As a good continuation/conclusion to my last post, I figured to give you a birds eye view at my thought process behind my own blog subscriptions.
Where I find them, how I choose them, the criteria they must meet, etc.
This could get…..interesting. In fact, the following article has the markings for getting sticky, in a controversial way. Controversy is good, it’s healthy, as long as it remains intelligent.
I debated with myself quite a bit as to whether I should even republish this or not, nearly as much as I debated whether to write and publish it in the first place.
Then I remembered; opposing sides, with every right to their opinions, just make me giggle.
The fact is, there are MANY bloggers that feel the same way I do in what you’re about to read, but are for whatever reason, afraid to say it.
Like they would be admitting something evil.
What is this ridiculous evilness regarding? The fact that we bloggers want to associate or align ourselves with fellow bloggers that understand what blogging is all about; the *big picture* as it were.
Creating relationships and community. Those that give something back to the people that matter most…..readers.
You’ll understand this better in a minute…
This is the type question I’m asked OFTEN.
“I see you EVERYWHERE. How do you read and comment on so many blogs, so consistently, and have great comments nearly every time?”
“What is your criteria for doing so? What makes a blog worthy of your subscription?”
This article should cover that in a nutshell. A large nut, but a nutshell none the less. As I eluded to above though, some are sure to have a problem with it.
Ain’t that just a shame?
I’ll start by saying an alternate title could be: Blog Commenting – Methods to my Madness, seeing how my subscriptions and commenting habits have everything to do with each other.
I comment on every blog I subscribe to and only subscribe to blogs I feel I want to comment on.
This is 99.9% true. I do subscribe to a few with no desire to comment. I skim these articles for possible golden nuggets.
At the time of last publishing, I was subscribed to a little over 50 blogs (currently about 30).
I attempt to read and comment on every single article that hits my email, to the best of my ability. I do not spam, I do not leave crap simply for the back-link.
Many bloggers will tell you, all my comments are up to snuff and then some, where applicable. ![]()
OK Pick your jaw up off the floor, it’s not nearly as rough as it sounds. Not all bloggers post daily or even every other day, so 50 blogs does not mean 50 articles per day.
Like everything else, I work it into my daily schedule. This way it’s part of my daily plan, and not a “distraction” as so many seem to wrongfully call it.
I’ll read maybe 10-15 per day; this can be done quickly enough.
When done correctly blog commenting can easily be a major source of targeted traffic and one of the best ways to build relationships with blog owners and their other readers…
Two things you should be doing as often as possible anyway.
Why anyone would call this a distraction is beyond me. I’ll tell ya what though, the more you comment with consistency, you WILL get faster at reading and writing, while still remaining non-spammy.
As stated in the last post, which should be read if not already, this time I’m planning to completely change up my blog subscription process. Start a new list from scratch, with a whole new batch of blogs.
The first time around (a couple years ago now) I used Entrecard. It was an awesome place to find hundreds of blogs easily in just about any niche you could imagine; probably still is, but I haven’t been there in some time.
This time I’m taking more of an organic approach. Enabling me to give back a little more to my readers as well.
Those that comment on any one of my blogs will get first crack at me subscribing to theirs. From there it will be commentluv links on their blogs…..the reader of my reader and all that. ![]()
The simple explanation: Time is a commodity, you gotta show me a little something. Know what I mean?
1. Personality/Personability.
2. “LUV”.
3. Content of High Quality.
Lets break this down a little…..
Personality is the easiest to spot, right off the bat. Is your blog written like a tech manual?
Personability might take a little longer to figure out, but not too much. Are you a bitch? (Male or Female). Example: If you don’t reply to comments or emails, or you reply in a manner that comes across as “yea, thanks”…buh bye!
These two are first and foremost. You need to be personable in both your writing, and within YOU. Granted they are largely interchangeable; you won’t find too many with personality not being personable.
On that note, there are two things readers and writers should be careful with and wary of. Shyness and sarcasm; which should not be misread, but often are.
What it all comes down to is: Am I feeling comfortable enough to contact you? For a chat; a question; maybe to become friends or a possible partnership opportunity?
Honestly, I’ve had comment and/or email “conversations” with just about every blogger I subscribe too…some messenger and even phone too.
That’s what it’s all about!
As I said though, this can take a bit of time. I know I’m not going to be the bloggers best friend on the first visit. A few maybe, the bubblier ones. (I’m not linking, but you know who you are, LOL)
LUV: Let the controversy begin. Oy. Just like many others, this is another hot debate topic of late.
“Should a blog commenter concentrate more on blogs that offer some LUV in return, via certain WordPress plugins.”
(Do Follow, Commentluv, Keywordluv, Top Commenter, etc.)
Well, quite frankly, as my regulars can vouch, I am one that say’s, Yes.
When I first hit a new blog, I immediately scroll to the bottom of the comment section to view what the blogger may or may not offer his/her readers for their time and commitment.
There I said it again. Feel free to scroll down, call me a Selfish Dick and unsubscribe. I’ll try not to step on you on my way up.
Why do I do this horrible thing?
Because I know the true meaning and value of blogging; building communities and relationships first, which in turn brings traffic to my own site second.
What’s mine is yours; not what’s mine is mine and what’s yours is mine…..PR sculpting anyone?
The second reason is equally important and I mentioned it briefly above. TIME. A rare commodity indeed. I give mine to those that give to others, first and foremost.
If you don’t give a crap about me as a reader, why waste my valuable time on you? I wish to get to know as many fellow bloggers as I can, in the time allotted; so yea, I’m choosing those that know what it is to build a community and relationships first.
Sensing a general theme yet?
If you don’t offer anything back to your community, yet you still expect my email address; oh my you best have some extra special mojo there.
Don’t fret though, you have a chance. Scroll up and you’ll see it’s a solid .1%.
So now you’re screaming, but you said you don’t comment for back-links!? Hellooo did you just come in? Back-links have NOTHING to do with it. Links are for search engines, I’m all for the humans.
Besides, those that choose do follow blogs just for back-links, know very little about do follow. (Watch for an article on this.)
Content Quality: OK so you’ve been itchin’ to find out why in the world I would place this last?? Content is KING, isn’t it? Well, yea I suppose.
We need to face reality though, unless you’re in some out-of-the-way niche or even micro-niche, you’re NOT altogether unique.
Sorry to be the one to break it to you.
There’s a real high probability that I will find your info on another blog not too far away. This is where personability; your own “voice” comes into play.
If Tom and Jane write the same niche, but Tom bores the crap outa me; Jane gets my email.
Yes, it is THAT simple.
Don’t get me wrong, I absolutely skim the content a good bit before subscribing. After all, you could be the nicest person on the net, supply more luv then any other blogger, but if your writing is TOTAL crap…see ya ’round!
So that’s me. That’s the whole HOW & WHY of my subscribing to/reading/and commenting on other blogs. And yea, haha, I am so not alone.
It all comes down to this: Be personable, share some luv around the sphere, and of course, have some good stuff to read. I/We only have so much time to visit so many blogs.
If your writing is the same basic premise as John/Jane’s why should I read yours?
Still love me? Hate me? Agree with me, or no? Hit me with it! Be not afraid. As always, love me or hate me, I will never delete any intelligent comment.
Related posts:
Tags: Blog Subscriptions, Blogger Tips, Blogging
April 28th, 2010 at 7:16 am
RT @DennisEdell Blog Subscriptions – Methods to my Madness part 2 of 2 http://bit.ly/diBjZ3
Twitter: kbloemendaal
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 7:28 am
Well, you know I am not going to call you a “Dickhead” or unsubscribe, I think every blogger has to make their decisions based on their own methods.
Personally, the “luv” you speak of, isn’t really “luv” at all. Comment links are not SEO, they are advertising. The “ad copy” is your comment. If you write a good “ad copy”, people will notice it and click through to your site.
Google has already stated (many times) that comment links do not get weighed, so this “luv” doesn’t matter either.
After releasing my free ebook, I can tell you, 95% of the people that are downloading it, and signing up for mt list, are people that have NEVER commented on my site. The ones I do recognize as regulars, downloaded and then unsubscribed. I am starting to see how little value the commentors really are. Other than providing a conversation on my site, and some of them I consider “real” friends, most likely none of them will ever buy anything from my site…
So, after all that, if I changed to a third party app like Disqus, would that be the end of seeing you?
.-= Keith @ Blog Tips´s last blog ..Social Media Soap Opera =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 5:51 pm
@Keith @ Blog Tips,
First, I finally see at least one reason we’re clashing. To me, and other smart ones like yourself, “luv” does NOT equal SEO. This I do know.
When “I” talk about the luv, it has nothing to do with SEO. I’m sorry that wasn’t clear in the post above. I KNOW comment links hold little SEO value. I’m right beside you buddy tellin’ folks not to comment for the SEO value in a comment backlink.
When I use the word luv, it’s in the traditional sense, so to speak.
The plugins were created to give even a small token of appreciation to those that add value through a comment.
Do follow was created back when it really did make an SEO difference, no matter what Cutts says NOW. Even now, it does make an itsy bitsy difference, but its something.
Same with Keywordluv, used properly with the right anchor text…it’s the only explanation I have for my About page hitting a PR3 in it’s first dance lol.
Even without SEO advantages, you still give the commentor an opportunity to put something there to bio his site a bit.
Commentluv, the one that means the most to me, has absolutely nothing to do with SEO and never claimed to.
That one really is all about giving a little back with an article link.
Does this clear up any misaligned communication?
Disqus – Will I stop commenting because you no longer offer commentluv?
No. Since I already know and love you. lol. I know what you have to offer in the way of content…..assuming I don’t pick up another 20 blogs offering commentluv. haha
But, yea man, you’re gonna lose people and it has nothing to do with plugins; it has to do with people sick of logging into something just to comment.
This is something I swore I would never do, and I don’t on blogs that make you log into the blog itself and wait for a fricken password…..Disqus isn’t much better.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Ari Answered Your Questions; Intriguing Post =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 5:54 pm
@Keith @ Blog Tips, Please read…
http://www.robswebtips.com/how-your-readers-make-you-money-without-you-knowing-it/
[Reply]
Sire
Twitter: LottoMan01
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 6:54 pm
@Keith @ Blog Tips, Actually I’m not so sure this is true. Sure Google may say that, but it could be just to discourage people from using that method.
If I were to check my backlinks the majority would be from comments I’ve left either in blog or forum comments. There ain’t that many people linking directly to me.
At the moment I have a PR4, not that I care for PR, but I attribute that to commenting.
Once again, I don’t care about PR so I don’t care if I’m wrong about this so shoot me down if it makes you feel better
I comment because I enjoy it and because I know the ‘ad’ value that your talking about and if that brings me more traffic then that’s cool.
.-= Sire´s last blog ..How Commentluv And Keyword Luv Can Boost Your Comments =-.
[Reply]
Keith from Blog Tips
Twitter: kbloemendaal
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 7:10 pm
@Sire, I can assure you that people link to you, I have linked to your articles in the past, and I no at least 5 or six other sites I have seen your links in articles I was reading.
I know how you feel about Google and Matt Cutts, but I have actually ran tests with mine and other sites to back up my claims. I know one site that has only 50 links, not one of them from a comment or forum, and that site is a PR4 with some internal pages having PR5. Then I have another site with 25k links mostly from comments and forums and it remains a PR2. Both sites are over 3yrs old, have around the same number of indexed pages, and are even in similar niches.
So, it isn’t so much what Google or Matt says, but what I have found from my own testing as well.
I never believe everything somebody says, but I do try to test things on my own sites so that I can determine for myself.
And of course I would never shoot you down
My findings are just that, my findings. And I always tell people (or at least try to) that it may work differently on your site….
Overall, it is my belief that comment links, forum links, and directory have little if any affect on PR (not that anybody cares about PR
)
.-= Keith @ Blog Tips´s last blog ..Hot Blog Tips Now Uses Disqus =-.
[Reply]
Sire
Twitter: LottoMan01
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 7:24 pm
@Keith @ Blog Tips, Cool, and I’m not about to run tests on my blog to prove you wrong because it’s just not important enough to me.
Besides, like I said, it ain’t the PR I’m looking for, it’s the interaction. To me, that’s what blogging is all about.
.-= Sire´s last blog ..Scientific Revelation Explaining Why Some A Listers Are Assholes =-.
[Reply]
Rob
Twitter: todayhaspower
Reply:
April 29th, 2011 at 7:28 pm
@Keith,
I’m new to the ins and outs of this, but… Re: ‘I know one site that has only 50 links, not one of them from a comment or forum, and that site is a PR4 with some internal pages having PR5. Then I have another site with 25k links mostly from comments and forums and it remains a PR2.’
The comparison I see is 25K and 50 links.
25,000 links compared to 50? Is this right? ‘Mostly comments and forums’, means not all. Did the other links not count for anything? Again just trying to get a hold of this.
Do you have an actual case study I can look at?
Thanks so much.
Rob recently posted..Interview With C Hollingsworth From Smart Boy Designs
[Reply]
Twitter: freemanlegacy
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 9:32 am
I like what Kieth said “Other than providing a conversation on my site, and some of them I consider “real” friends, most likely none of them will ever buy anything from my site…”
Although I enjoy reading and replying to the many comments on my blog, as far as revenue goes they are not the life’s blood of my blog.
I don’t agree with deleting comments left on my blog because I don’t find them to be on par intellectually with me. The person took the time to stop, read and voice an opinion-I respect that.
As, far as gaining email addresses here’s my thoughts on that. With the millions of folks on the internet, I hardly think anyone is going to fret over following an individuals criteria for signing up. I just put up my enrollment form over the weekend and I already have 40 subscribers….
Blogging isn’t rocket science: What goes around comes around, and reciprocity prevails.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 5:55 pm
@Ms. Freeman@Baby Steps of an Internet Entrepreneur, I gave this to Keith also…
http://www.robswebtips.com/how-your-readers-make-you-money-without-you-knowing-it/
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Blog Subscriptions – Methods to my Madness part 2 of 2 =-.
[Reply]
Keith from Blog Tips
Twitter: kbloemendaal
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 8:22 pm
@Dennis Edell, Read the article, and left a comment, I am sure Rob will like it, but I think this is a great discussion, even though it is getting off topic for your article, and I should probably follow it up with a post. Thanks for the ideas! LOL
.-= Keith @ Blog Tips´s last blog ..Meet James Richmond =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:39 am
@Keith @ Blog Tips, Anytime! LOL
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: selurus
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 4:25 pm
Well currently I’m subscribed to way too many blogs than I can handle. I’ll probably need to apply you technique and sort them before my reading list looks like a library.
About commenting I don’t really care about link luv, I comment whenever I have something to say that adds to the post I’ve just read.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 28th, 2010 at 5:19 pm
@Selurus,
Me too, which is why I do care. Confused? lol
I comment on every blog I subscribe to and only subscribe to blogs I feel I want to comment on.
Remember that? I don’t subscribe to a blog unless I can tell ahead of time, that I am going to have something to add.
So, if I am going to spend all that continuous time, why not want it to be mutual?
That make sense?
If you want, shoot me an email and I’ll reply with the spreadsheet I talked about.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Blog Subscriptions – Methods to my Madness part 2 of 2 =-.
[Reply]
April 28th, 2010 at 5:39 pm
I’m not entirely sure what is so controversial here. Never having given it too much thought up to now, I looked over the subscriptions in my RSS reader (a fair mix from the famous a-listers right on down), and I came to a pretty similar conclusion to Dennis.
The blogs I repeatedly return to and comment on are the ones where I connect to the personality and the writing style. I rarely find that connection with the so called a-listers, and see no reason to add to the 200 or so “right on John, you the man, you rock!” type comments that they get on each and every post from star struck link builders.
As Keith pointed out above, I know my regular commenters are unlikely to buy anything from me, but they certainly do add to the community and life of my blog.
.-= Des @ Affiliate Progress´s last blog ..Why Do You Want To Be An Affiliate Marketer? =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: DennisEdell
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 5:58 pm
“but they certainly do add to the community and life of my blog.”
Which is after all the ONLY reason to go blog over static site. lol Thanks!
I gave this link to Keith and Des also…
http://www.robswebtips.com/how-your-readers-make-you-money-without-you-knowing-it/
[Reply]
Twitter: LottoMan01
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 6:56 pm
I’m subscribed to blogs but I don’t use it. People have said the same about seeing me everywhere and I do it simply by following my commentators to their blogs. From there I may find a comment that I like and I hop over to their blog and it snowballs from there.
.-= Sire´s last blog ..Scientific Revelation Explaining Why Some A Listers Are Assholes =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:40 am
@Sire, You don’t use what exactly?
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Sire
Twitter: LottoMan01
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 8:51 pm
@Dennis Edell, Well, when I subscribe I choose Google Reader and I reckon I’m lucky if I use it once a month to check on updates.
.-= Sire´s last blog ..Stand By Me And We Will Become Better Bloggers =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 1st, 2010 at 10:05 am
@Sire, I know it man, and the main reason I gave up on feed readers long ago…also the reason I offer a small incentive for subscribing via email.
http://www.dennisedell.com/email-subscribers/
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Comment Contest April – – Winners! =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: anneonline
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 10:13 pm
Off topic, but what really got my attention was the new window/same window for links. I control clicked to force it into a new window so I could continue with this article, then go check out the other when I was done.
Back on point, I see nothing wrong in wanting something in return for your time. It reminds me of this guy I once worked with. He loved this girl who was quite a bit younger than he. They had an affair some years prior, but now she had a young child. He was happy, sort of. Then one day he told her he couldn’t do this. His kids were just about grown and what he really wanted was to be able to date someone with whom he could take off to NY with [or anywhere really] at a moments notice. He asked me if he was being a jerk. You like him are just being honest about what you want in your relationship. What more can another person ask for. This way everyone knows upfront what it expected and no one should be let down if it doesn’t work out.
.-= Anne Bender´s last blog ..Meet, well, ME! =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:38 am
@Anne Bender,
True enough, although it’s not just what “I” want in return.
I check to see if they’re giving something back to the community as a whole.
Welcome to the blog!
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: suzannefranco
Says:
April 28th, 2010 at 10:48 pm
Wow! Wow! Am I glad that I popped over … I read a lot of my RSS via my Blackberry (with 5 kids I have to organize my time by what can be done while sitting in a car, at a doctor’s office, at a practice, etc.) so I don’t always get the chance to comment on all of the posts I’ve enjoyed. I would rather come all the way to the site just for this reason … I find very often that the comments add a great deal to the post itself. I am at a point where I too need to prioritize the RSS feed and see where I might cut some out (that are just not a fit for me).
I can’t say for sure but it seems like my inbound links in Yahoo are there in “order” of PR and/or importance. (does anyone know on this one?). If that’s true … I do see comments I’ve left on higher PR blogs towards the top of that list … which causes me to believe that they give some credit based on PR.
I would never subscribe or comment based on PR … I’m … well not into that (I think that’s a pretty newbie move myself LOL).
Thanks for the great post and I also enjoyed all of the comments … it’s all food for thought.
Now … I’m off to be sexy (<—- ya know … spread the luv for ya!) *huGs* S
.-= Suzanne@Money Making Ideas´s last blog ..Are You Sexy? We’re About to Find Out! =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:34 am
@Suzanne@Money Making Ideas,
It is a newbie move, and one they’re learning from old schoolers…back in the day, it really did make a difference.
You’re quite right, I’ve always said a good comments section can add serious mojo to the article, if not even provide more info!
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
April 28th, 2010 at 10:49 pm
RT @DennisEdell Blog Subscriptions–Methods to my Madness part 2 of 2 http://bit.ly/diBjZ3 (be sure you read the comments too! they're great)
April 28th, 2010 at 11:26 pm
The day we met you were already a prolific commenter (the same can be said of @Peter Sire). Fast forward today, you still ARE.
Perhaps the difference between you and the rest of bloggers is that you value the relationship more than anything else while others assume that commenting is way to build links and eventually make money.
Sorry for staying under the radar. You’re not done with your theme yet, are you?
Be well, buddy.
Cheers
Yan
.-= Yan@Blogging Tips´s last blog ..5 Pop Culture Quotes for a Memorable Blog =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:31 am
@Yan@Blogging Tips,
It’s awesome to see someone realize that, thanks man.
Nope, not even close my friend.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
April 29th, 2010 at 12:08 am
As you know, Dennis, I subscribe to more than 200, but not all of those are something I comment on. However, I have commented at least once on all of them; I follow for information.
And you’re right, going through 10 to 15 blogs a day is no problem at all, and nothing says you absolutely have to comment on something that doesn’t hit you. For instance, many poetry blogs just go past me, so I don’t comment when I see those.
.-= Mitch´s last blog ..Why I Created A Facebook Fan Page =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:29 am
@Mitch,
True enough. While I do only subscribe to those I feel I’ll comment on (98%), I don’t necessarily comment on every post.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
April 29th, 2010 at 4:21 am
Thanks for the link Dennis. I have to agree with the ideas Rob puts forward there.
.-= Des @ Affiliate Progress´s last blog ..Why Do You Want To Be An Affiliate Marketer? =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:25 am
@Des @ Affiliate Progress,
me too. It’s one of the reasons I have always concentrated on the community aspect over almost anything else.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: clickonportal
Says:
April 29th, 2010 at 2:15 pm
I actually do see you everywhere, like seriously. I personally spend about 50-50 blogging and promoting. But if I had to spend more time in one, it would be the content. No use promoting a useless post I always say. I make sure all are my best.
.-= Mici@ Click On Portal´s last blog ..Date Night to Remember =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:18 am
@Mici@ Click On Portal, Its best to stay 50-50 IMO, but yes, if a HAVE TO comes along, then it’s content.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Says:
April 29th, 2010 at 3:17 pm
I comment every now and again. I don’t have a tight schedule or anything like that. Typically I do so when I see an okay post or if I’m first.
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..No Time To Loose (PR 3 in 50 Days) =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 11:10 am
@Tini@Inzone Internet, Needing to be first is a myth, I’ll be posting on that eventually.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
ini from TInzone Internet
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Reply:
May 5th, 2010 at 7:04 am
@Dennis Edell, Hmm…I don’t think so. I comment on No Follow Blogs too, so a more visible link is good. I have made a post on this, check commentluv. Of course, it is open to debates.
Also, since the more outbound links there are the less link juice you get, being first is always good. You don’t want to comment in a post with a hundred links. Take advantage while there is still a few, like if you are the first few to comment.
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..No Follow Also Helps =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 5th, 2010 at 11:15 am
@Tini@Inzone Internet,
Visible links are good, yes, which is why I go for commentluv blogs.
Link Juice – if you’re first and there are 99 comments under you….#1 is going to get the same juice as #100.
Overall it doesn’t matter, one shouldn’t comment for link juice. There’s very little no matter how many are there.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Would You Like to Read a TRUE Make Money Online Blog? Part 1 =-.
[Reply]
ini from TInzone Internet
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Reply:
May 6th, 2010 at 7:24 am
@Dennis Edell, Sorry about this but I have to disagree on some of your points.
There is a BIG difference if you are 1st to comment or 100th. Google Bots are also known to only “eat” links until they are full and no longer crawl the rest of your page. They would continue to crawl at about 40-50 at a small site post while 100-200 in bigger sites. So if you are 100th in a small site would you be detected? Nope. So it is not good to have all your minor tags all over your front page because they will not get crawled on.
Comments matter for link juice. I know of companies who comment hundreds a week. Do they do that for branding? No. It’s not good to be considered a spammer, but they do it anyway. This is because EVERY link juice count and sums up to a huge surge in page rank.
You need FRESH new links every time as link juice degrades as a post gets placed at the back end of your site and goes unnoticed.
Of course, you are welcome to think otherwise Dennis.
I’m just saying this based on what I know. And if you don’t think the way I do, then it’s better for me as you can let me comment first 
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..Another Do Follow 101 Post =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 6th, 2010 at 9:00 am
@Tini@Inzone Internet,
Never apologize for healthy debate…I don’t. lol
However, your entire rebuttal revolves around the idea that commenting FOR backlinks is a good idea; it is not.
Yes indeed. Hundreds upon hundreds upon hundreds upon………. may add up some.
You don’t see the flaw in this “logic”?
And yes, they are most likely nothing but spammers. If they’re commenting on blogs that mean anything, very few are getting through anyway.
No offense, but you’re seriously taking advice from these sorts? Please don’t give them my URL’s, I’d hate to have to get their sites shut down.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Would You Like to Read a TRUE Make Money Online Blog? Part 1 =-.
[Reply]
ini from TInzone Internet
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 5:29 am
@Dennis Edell, You didn’t take much into consideration my key point, where EVERY link counts for link juice. I comment about 10 a day and for me that is already good enough. It really depends on your niche, if you are competing with Amazon then you obviously need more links in.
I don’t take advice from companies, I worship the SEO blog gods of the Internet World. If it works for them then it works for me, and I’ve read loads too. (And you have angered the SEO blog gods by saying Do Follow backlinks don’t count for much and we must appease them now. lol)
If you are commenting and not thinking that it is mainly for link juice then that is the flawed “logic”. I would think that someone who comments as much as you do would see more value in what you are doing.
Alright, I take it back, I’m not sorry.
Peace!
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..No Time To Loose (PR 3 in 50 Days) =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 9:00 am
@Tini@Inzone Internet,
I absolutely took your key point into consideration, when i wrote, “Hundreds upon hundreds upon hundreds upon………. may add up some.”
Sorry, if your MAIN purpose for commenting is backlinks then it’s a bad move, and any “SEO” saying so is off their rocker.
Commenting is for building relationships…the do follow backlink is a decent side-effect…eventually.
Hey, I’ve been a do-follow user and advocate since it started, literally. I installed the very first plugin after it came out of BETA testing. I’ve learned a lot since then.
Yes it helps with SEO, a little here and there, but should never EVER be the sole reason for commenting.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..I Need MORE Aweber USER Affiliates! =-.
[Reply]
ini from TInzone Internet
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 11:28 am
@Dennis Edell,
*Just wanna say that this is all for healthy debate, and is no way trying to disrespect anyone’s opinion.*
That’s not my key point. The key point is EVERY BACKLINK COUNTS, where a few do follow links here and there is okay for a small blog like ours, and each backlink is very important. You DON’T NEED hundreds upon hundreds unless you are a major company, so what you stated as my key point was not my key point.
Like I said, I comment 10 a day and I feel that will get me PR 3 perhaps with good content, I don’t need hundreds upon hundreds a day. A major company needs hundreds upon hundreds, and I’m not a major company.
Of course do follow links are not the “sole reason for commenting” BUT do follow links are not the “decent side effect” as you called it. The side effect is the “building relationships” part.
Let me explain…
If you comment then you get at most 2 to 4 people to see your comment and visit your site and maybe gain a few friends in the process…
BUT
if you comment with a do follow backlink WITH the RIGHT KEYWORDS, you will eventually rank up for those keywords in the Google Search Engine (hence the term “Search Engine Optimization”… they don’t call it the “Build Relationships Optimization” or BRO.)
MEANING
You can get hundreds of visitors through Google natural search BECAUSE of your do follow link. If you are on top of their search list, chances are you will get clicked by A LOT of people. This is why people spam comment EVEN WITHOUT RELATIONSHIPS. Hell you don’t need relationships to get in Google Search.
Contrary to how you think, these spammers are usually smarter than both of us on knowing how to gain traffic and page rank. For goodness sake, that is THEIR JOB. That’s what they do for a living so they STUDY LINKS thoroughly, and they say to hell with relationships. With what you are saying, you are in fact disagreeing with a lot of genius SEO spammers.
Still think it’s a “decent side-effect”?
If you call eventually gaining LOTS of readers from natural Google search “decent”.
People hugely prefer do follow blogs for a reason, and they are not dumb for that.
Although I have to point out that I believe in the “building relationships part” as well. I put a meaningful comment in ALL blogs including No Follow to hit 2 birds with one stone.
That gets me back to saying my other point that you need to be in the first few comments for:
1. People to see you (your building relationships part)
2. Google to crawl on you if site is do follow (my SEO part)
If you comment just about anywhere, like you present, you don’t hit both birds. lol
Do Follow Links are important, no matter how you disagree with what I am saying. I also happen to have a few decent SEO Blogger friends that can validate my statements, so it’s not just the spammers, or me.
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..Why I KeywordLuv =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 11:45 am
@Tini@Inzone Internet,
I never said *Just wanna say that this is all for healthy debate, and is no way trying to disrespect anyone’s opinion.* was your key point.
2-4 visitors? Wow are you commenting in the wrong places, or with the wrong comments; sorry, waaaay more then that here, it’s my main source of traffic and my personal SEO is very low.
Other then that, well OK then, enjoy.
Btw, I’ve phished every single comment of yours since you started here out of the spam filter, you might wanna look into that.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..I Need MORE Aweber USER Affiliates! =-.
[Reply]
ini from TInzone Internet
Twitter: inzoneinternet
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 6:45 pm
@Dennis Edell, Hey! I actually comment pretty decently
I would think that each comment from a post would get just that, 2-4 clicks, especially if you are in the middle part of comments, not a lot of people read comments. Of course, adding all that together would be something, the way yours work.
I think the fact that you have a lot of links out there means you’re doing decent SEO, even if you don’t realize it.
Right now you are just building up your site (like which plugins to use, etc), BUT once you get more of the personal coaching in here with the right keywords on your post in text (not just links), you’ll get more traffic naturally from Google, which is more effective in the long run.
Hmm… if you phish out every comment I make from spam filter then I think YOU gotta look into that. If you’ve been approving my comments then it should be not in spam filter now. There’s also the option of “automatically approving a person after this number of comments”, but of course, not everyone is into that. I actually check if my comments get approved in sites and it does. If most go to spam filter then a lot of bloggers wouldn’t even see it, but apparently they do. I don’t have a lot of comments so it’s easier to check.
.-= Tini@Inzone Internet´s last blog ..New to Blogging? BlogEngage VS Digg Comparison =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 7th, 2010 at 7:51 pm
@Tini@Inzone Internet,
I’ve always gotten tons more traffic, subscribers, etc., from blog commenting then SEO, or anything else for that matter
Again my friend, you not me. I do have it set on auto after 1-2 comments and approve each. Your on a hit list for sure. Contacting Akismet might be a good idea.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..I Need MORE Aweber USER Affiliates! =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: imstrategies
Says:
April 30th, 2010 at 1:39 am
Dennis, you are the Blog Comment King of the Universe!
I agree with you on many points, and if every single blog I read and commented on was full of great content, well, then I would only be reading a lot less blogs.
I take the personality and interaction abilities of the blogger as much more important than their content, if I like you, I’m there!
.-= JR @ Internet Marketing ´s last blog ..How To Check Links on Websites and Blogs Automatically =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 10:57 am
@JR @ Internet Marketing, Welcome aboard! lol
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
April 30th, 2010 at 1:00 pm
Thanks for the interesting post. I personally prefer using nofollow on commentor links because it (might) make the other links (such as in the post itself) proportionately more useful.
What do you think?
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 4:48 pm
@Nate @ Practical Manliness, This seems to be the primary argument among no followers. Personally I have seen no concrete evidence either way.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
April 30th, 2010 at 2:46 pm
Read: Blog Comment – Methods to my madness http://is.gd/bOBlc
Twitter: selurus
Says:
April 30th, 2010 at 2:46 pm
@Dennis Edell, I guess he is referring to his feed reader probably something like Google Reader.
A feed reader is an awesome tool but it gets overwhelming when you’ve got too many subscriptions and not enough time. I’ve got to clear my reading list, got just too many unread articles at the moment.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2010 at 4:42 pm
@Selurus, Who?
That’s just one reason why I hate feed readers.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..What are YOUR Top 3 Social Sharing Recommendations =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: selurus
Says:
April 30th, 2010 at 2:52 pm
@Sire, I too end up comment hopping these day. A lot of blogs now have comment luv and some titles are just too interesting to leave unexplored.
[Reply]
Twitter: selurus
Says:
May 1st, 2010 at 4:16 am
@Dennis Edell, I was referring to Sire’s comment. I wonder why this comment didn’t appear as nested?
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 1st, 2010 at 9:59 am
@Selurus, Are you sure you hit the reply link? If yes, then I have no idea, sorry.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Comment Contest April – – Winners! =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: goldenkoi
Says:
May 4th, 2010 at 1:09 pm
Hey Dennis! Haven’t been here for a while and I must say that the blog is looking really good as I recall when you were changing the theme etc. … I see it is still a work in progress, but then every blog is!
OK … of topic!
Back to topic: I schedule commenting time. I think it is an important activity for bloggers. Whether the backlink generated feeds SEO or not, commenting does generate traffic. I don’t have a system for my commenting though, more often than not it as someone mentioned earlier here more like comment hopping.
What I have found via commenting is a whole new community and blogs that I would otherwise not be aware of. I learn more from comments and the blogs that those comments lead me to.
.-= Valentina´s last blog ..Collecting Experiences vs Things =-.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 4th, 2010 at 1:40 pm
@Valentina, Very well put, I rally appreciate the input.
If I may, I strongly suggest putting some sort of system into place. It takes a while, but well well worth it once you’re in place.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..Updated: Do You USE Aweber? I Want Your Affiliate Link. Part 2 =-.
[Reply]
Twitter: colleenlane
Says:
May 9th, 2010 at 1:24 pm
Essentially, we subscribe to many blogs for the same reason as you do Dennis. We subscribe to blogs we want to learn from and comment on. Surprises me so few of my competitors are not doing more blog subscriptions and blog commenting. There is a lot to learn.
=-.
.-= Colleen@Kennewick Real Estate´s last blog ..Happy Mothers Day, ~ The Lane Real Estate Team
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 9th, 2010 at 1:42 pm
@Colleen@Kennewick Real Estate,
I’m thinkin’ an educational article written by the knowledgeable (you) towards realtors on this subject would be an excellent idea.
Whatcha think?
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..I Need MORE Aweber USER Affiliates! =-.
[Reply]
Colleen from Kennewick Real Estate
Twitter: colleenlane
Reply:
May 10th, 2010 at 12:31 am
@Dennis Edell, Yeah, you are right, and we have. We are involved in a real estate blogging network called ActiveRain.com and folks don’t want to listen! Real estate agents tend to crawl over each other to see who is the most popular real estate agent, not realizing other agents are not their source of income, it’s the home buyer or seller.
=-.
.-= Colleen@Kennewick Real Estate´s last blog ..Happy Mothers Day, ~ The Lane Real Estate Team
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 10th, 2010 at 6:25 pm
@Colleen@Kennewick Real Estate,
Y’ar a competirive lot, arentcha. lol. I witnessed 1 agent swipe a client (my friend) away from another right there in the same office.
Of course the 1st deserved it, she was really lazy and a bit obnoxious…..like we were making her work or something. lol
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..A TRUE Make Money Online blog – Part 2 – Choose My Domain Name =-.
[Reply]
May 19th, 2010 at 9:06 am
I was never a fan of blog commenting for my SEO activities. What enticed my to do this is when I joined a SEO contest and noticed that the winner had so much bacllinks and most of them are through blog commenting. This means that blog commenting (luv) is effective as far as ranking is concerned.
Not only that. I followed the linking pattern of one of our competitors and found out that most of the links for their site are coming from blog commenting. Just my two cents…
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 19th, 2010 at 11:23 am
@James @ Wealth Education,
SEO should never be the #1 reason for blog commenting, but it is an awesome benefit sometimes.
Welcome aboard the blog!
I took a minute to visit you (I’ll be back) to find your name. I changed the name field in your comments to match my comment policy (name @ KW’s), and it’s also better for you SEO wise.
.-= Dennis Edell´s last blog ..10 Social Share Sites Chosen – Do You Agree? =-.
[Reply]
October 30th, 2010 at 2:17 am
It is right if you read post on daily bases and write comments on each post. Both of your skills that reading and writing will be improved a lot.Your will work of hours in minutes.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
November 1st, 2010 at 9:42 am
@Raj@ielts, Exactly right, you just need to be consistent.

Dennis Edell recently posted..My Agenda – What’s Comming – You’ll Want to Read This!
[Reply]
Twitter: 20milesnorth
Says:
November 1st, 2010 at 12:09 pm
I agree that the point of keyword/comment luv is in inspire more interaction. You have no idea how many sites I have poked in and actually came back later because I ‘discovered’ them through one of these plugins, just nosing around. Its real contributors that are the value in these things to me.
Rob@Spokane Website Design recently posted..20 Miles North Web Design Blog now with Comment Luv
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
November 3rd, 2010 at 4:48 pm
@Rob@Spokane Website Design,
Exactly, this is what I try to get though to the nay-sayers.
Just because they were drawn in by my plugins, don;t mean any crap they type will stick; i only keep the best of it.

Dennis Edell recently posted..What is YOUR Opinion on the Left & Right-Hand Sidebar WordPress Themes
[Reply]
December 16th, 2010 at 7:41 am
Comment luv and keyword luv are in my opinion very helpful and very interactable.I discoveerd a lot of helpful sites with these two tools, and they helped me to improve my bussiness
Cosmin Cornea@Fotograf nunta Timisoara recently posted..Fotografii botez Timisoara – Alexandru Florin
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
December 16th, 2010 at 7:48 am
@Cosmin Cornea@Fotograf nunta Timisoara,
Welcome to the community Cosmin, I hope to see you around here more often as well!

Dennis Edell recently posted..About The New All-In-One DennisEdellcom – Everything You Could Possibly Want to Know…
[Reply]
Twitter: darrenmonroe
Says:
February 27th, 2011 at 4:44 am
You know what Dennis? you are one of the most interesting and engaging guys I have some across.
IDEA: you should write whitepapers and market them. Based on the concentration of your writing and content you should do very well.
You have purpose…you matter.
Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas recently posted..My Brutally Honest Review of Profits Theme
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
March 1st, 2011 at 12:17 am
@Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas, Wow what an ego boost!
Here’s a good chance to ask this question…what exactly is a whitepaper – what’s it’s function?
OK possibly 2 questions there.

Dennis Edell recently posted..The Call To Action- All Good Copy Should Have One
[Reply]
Twitter: darrenmonroe
Says:
March 1st, 2011 at 11:30 am
Well historically whitepapers were actually grey, blue and other papers used by the government. They would write these papers up to infor people. i.e. a new railroad crossing needs to be a street X. Well the local rep in that area would have or write themselves a white paper on statistical data etc.
But as info became declassified in the government they became whitepapers vs other colors thus were called whitepapers. The education circles took up the word and its use for specific research papers or teachings. Many doctors have also written them based on a specific area of study.
NOW in marketing circles Dennis they are referred to this because they offer key info in more detail than the general blog and have links to resources and dare I SAY YES affiliate / product links at times.
It can be 50 pages long or short to the point funny stuff like the things I write on http://www.scribd.com . Either way it is a great way to build links and authority in your niche>
Hope that Clarifies
Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas recently posted..My Brutally Honest Review of Profits Theme
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
March 1st, 2011 at 11:50 am
@Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas,
Very informative Darren, thank you. I’ll look more into that.
Dennis Edell recently posted..March Comment Contest Begins! February Info Forthcoming…
[Reply]
April 9th, 2011 at 10:58 pm
darren, good post. Whenever I write content, I want it to be of quality and decent!
Fazal @ Make Money Online recently posted..5 WordPress Plugins That Will Make Your Blog Load Faster
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 10th, 2011 at 11:14 am
@Fazal @ Make Money Online, I welcome you to the community Fazal, but wonder what your comment has to do with the post above?
Btw, it’s Dennis not Darren
[Reply]
Darren Scott Monroe from Online Business Ideas
Twitter: darrenmonroe
Reply:
April 10th, 2011 at 11:20 am
@Dennis Edell, (laughing hard) I was wondering when you would join in on that one.
See he probably (though I could be wrong) scrolled to the bottom, didn’t read the top author and assumed it was me. OR I am soooo wonderful that my mere essence captured his attention to where he said DENNIS WHO? Darren MUST have written this HAHAHAHA! Have a great Sunday Dennis
Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas recently posted..Profits Theme Bonus
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 10th, 2011 at 11:33 am
@Darren Scott Monroe@ Online Business Ideas, LOL nice. I was wondering if it was you, which is why I always hope people use the actual reply links.
[Reply]
Twitter: rfcamat
Says:
April 14th, 2011 at 8:48 pm
I like subscribing to blogs that provide high quality posts even if they don’t update their blogs regularly. I hate blogs that post almost everyday, only to find out that what they wrote are all crap.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 15th, 2011 at 8:06 am
@raymund@dell toners, unfortunately this is mostly the case I’ve found. They are so obsessed with daily posting that the quality suffers greatly.
Dennis Edell recently posted..How Search Keywords Work
[Reply]
Twitter: Pianolessongirl
Says:
April 29th, 2011 at 6:48 pm
@Dennis,
Re: ‘I know I’m not going to be the bloggers best friend on the first visit. A few maybe, the bubblier ones.(I’m not linking, but you know who you are, LOL)’.
Thanks, and here I was going to keep it secret:)
I leave comments for backlinks first, and then relationships. There, I said it.
Are there really people trying to create a business out there who have nothing better to do than read blogs all day? If no kindness ‘luv’
is shown, I must move on. Most who are serious about this are no different, but may not want to voice it. It doesn’t change how I comment. I try to do that well even if my motives may be (allegedly) different than others. I will be right behind you on your way up, my friend.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
April 30th, 2011 at 8:49 am
@Dakota, It kinda sounds like you’re trying to disagree with me, when in reality we agree on the same thing…almost.
I don’t comment for links, because comment links are losing value quickly, soon they may have none.
As I sated in the post though, I do look for the luv first in the form of commentluv plugin…..98% of the blogs I comment on have it installed.

Dennis Edell recently posted..Link Building and List Building – A Blog or Newsletter
[Reply]
Dakota
Twitter: Pianolessongirl
Reply:
May 3rd, 2011 at 12:49 am
@Dennis Edell,
I am trying to grow my website. I am learning everyday, and reading your site has helped. I do however appreciate also the links I get from commenting here.
I wasn’t meaning to disagree, at least, not totally.
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 3rd, 2011 at 3:43 am
@Dakota, lol no worries, we’re good. I’m really glad my blog does help.
Appreciating the links is good, but don’t get too overly excited about them. Again, comment links are no longer worth nearly as much as many people tend to think.
Dennis Edell recently posted..@DennisEdell is Back Baby! Follow Me for First Chance -
[Reply]
Twitter: bigfeetmktg
Says:
May 1st, 2011 at 2:33 pm
Interesting approach, Dennis. I’m not too sure what is so controversial about it though, but maybe it’s just because I don’t disagree with you on much. This is the first time I’ve visited your site, but I must admit that I’ve seen you just about everywhere (including my own site now that I think of it).
I think that being everywhere, and leaving great comments, is a great way to introduce yourself to new readers – especially when you first start a blog. I’m not convinced that there isn’t an SEO impact, but even if there’s none the ubiquitous nature of your approach builds trust in your brand and ultimately traffic to your site.
Keep up the great comments, and I know I’ll see you around many times over.

Brad Harmon @ Big Feet Marketing recently posted..Don’t Let Your Website Be Held Hostage
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 1st, 2011 at 8:52 pm
@Brad Harmon @ Big Feet Marketing, Ridiculousness Brad. Controversial because some like to consider it, me only commenting for something in return, which is just not the point.
Welcome aboard!
I started seriously commenting a few years ago when I started my first serious blog. you’re quite right, a hell of a way to introduce yourself and my #1 traffic source since then.
SEO: Back in the day, when the do follow plugins were first introduced, do follow comment links were considered a holy grail, snapped up as fast as one could comment.
Now, Google itself, more to the point Matt Cutts has stated point blank, this just ain’t the case no more…their devaluing more and more as the days go by.
I hope to see you more as well! .;-)
Dennis Edell recently posted..Link Building and List Building – A Blog or Newsletter
[Reply]
Twitter: SheWritesaLot
Says:
May 4th, 2011 at 9:14 am
Hi Dennis,
Great post! And call me naive or an idiot or whatever.. but it never even occurred to me to think about link juice when I comment on blogs. I comment because I like what I read. And seriously? I usually leave a comment just to let the blogger know I appreciate the effort and add some activity to their blog.
And developing relationships? It’s nice when it happens but again it’s not my main purpose for commenting.
I guess I just don’t understand this whole ‘we’re all bloggers so we should stick together’ thing. Yeah, I like you and the other people who’ve left comments here all seem very nice, too. But as someone here said, the people leaving comments aren’t paying your bills.
So really, how important is it to make developing a relationship with 50 other generic bloggers a part of your daily business practice? Doesn’t it make more sense to spend that time developing relationships with someone who might actually buy something from you?
Sorry. Not trying to be negative at all. I guess what I’m asking is – do you see benefits from all of this activity other than developing relationships with other bloggers? I’ve recently been researching direct response marketing techniques and it all comes down to answering the question ‘What’s In It For Me?’ So, unfortunately, that’s my mindset lately.
BTW – I have you in my reader!
Donna Anderson recently posted..Who Cares About Traffic Your Articles Need To Make MONEY!
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 4th, 2011 at 6:32 pm
@Donna Anderson, First, you comment correctly; not for the backllink.
Now as for the relationship building, my favorite cliche` is, no blogger is an island. You cannot go it alone, eventually you ill need friendships in the form of bloggers.
I wouldn’t be doing a bunch of the stuff I’m doing now if it wasn’t for relationships made.
As for who is going to buy from you? I suppose some of that does depend on niche and the blogs you’re commenting on.
Using you as an example. You’re a freelance writer and wondering how blogger relationships can help? Really?

Dennis Edell recently posted..@DennisEdell is Back Baby! Follow Me for First Chance -
[Reply]
May 8th, 2011 at 3:35 am
You are what I call one of the new age bloggers. Your talking about stuff that people used to have to pay $1000 a month to hear from the Gubs of the internet.
Well some are still big money for the same stuff you and others are talking about now in an open way.
I live KeywordLUV, and I like do follow, but GAWDS do I hate the crap comments that come with it.
In the nine months since I started this blog, I have had about 20 good comments worth reading. The rest have been pure spammy junk. I mean the kind of spam that my dog would not even eat. lol
It’s depressing really. I put a lot of hard work into my current blog project, and honestly, I have just scratched the surface at turning my ereader blog into an authority site worth high PR. I do believe it deserves more than the PR 0 it has at the moment though.
I get a lot of traffic on my little PR 0 blog, just wish I could see some Goggle LUV. lol
Heilagr recently posted..Does The World Need A 3D Ereader – Tablet
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 8th, 2011 at 6:56 am
@Heilagr, Welcome to the community Heilagr, and thanks for all the kid words. Truth be told, I was doing this back then too. lol
I woke to 7 comments this morning, 6 spam and yours.

Dennis Edell recently posted..100 Down Thousands to Go!
[Reply]
Twitter: SuzyWeiss
Says:
May 10th, 2011 at 10:39 am
Dennis,
Kudos!
You put into words very clearly what I believed but didn’t have the clarity of thought to articulate it.
In the course of reading your post I came across one tiny two letter word that screams personality… at least to me.
That tiny two letter word?
Oy!
Priceless.
Suzy Weiss
Straight Talk For Divorced Women’s Dating Success
P.S. Found your blog from @webtrafficcafe. So, blog commenting works to build community!
Suzy Weiss recently posted..How To Meet Middle Aged Men – Mobilize A Mob Of Matchmakers!
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 11th, 2011 at 5:59 am
@Suzy Weiss, LOL thanks for the kudos Suzy, not to mention noticing the little things.
Welcome to the community!
[Reply]
Twitter: SalesSells
Says:
May 19th, 2011 at 12:51 pm
Awesome article Dennis. I’m still amazed at the amount of commenting you get done.
Commenting is indeed a great way to build your online presence and generate traffic. Also it gives you a good indication of the blog author’s attitude. Does he/she respond to your comment? Does he/she at least thank you? etc.
I see you’re replying to every comment made here, so you must be someone who reaches out, appreciates the community and likes to build relationships.
Awesome, I like that!
See you around,
Wim
Wim@Sales blog recently posted..“You Are Too Expensive” – Eight Ways To Handle Price Objections
[Reply]
Dennis Edell
Twitter: DennisEdell
Reply:
May 19th, 2011 at 3:11 pm
@Wim@Sales blog, Absolutely! I see the following progression…if you wish not to respond to comments, don’t have comments. If you’d rather not have comments, build static sites, not blogs.
Blogs are comments, and vise-verse.
[Reply]
August 12th, 2011 at 4:23 pm
I see this all over the internet now a days.. people making what I consider to be ‘spam posts’ just for the sake of it. I happen to write smaller posts than most, this is purely because I don’t want to fill a page with worthless text. Short, and to the point is what I strive for.
Rick@Bellingham SEO recently posted..WordPress Zero Day
[Reply]
August 16th, 2011 at 4:37 pm
Commentluv is really great i already install the wordpress commentluv plugins. Thanks for your very informative content about using commentluv and how it helps to a weblog
[Reply]
August 18th, 2011 at 1:49 am
Nice post friend….
air mass meter
[Reply]
September 12th, 2011 at 10:55 pm
Uniqueness of content writing to your blog is very much important for me. In leaving comment to a certain blog it must be relevant to the topic and grammatically correct. Thanks for sharing your ideas about it and I’m impress. Keep on sharing!
Khloe@Black Mold Removal recently posted..Mildew Removal
[Reply]